A Fanfic Rant

[sinanju]

Edit: This post is occasioned by amand_r's rant confession on her own livejournal and the comments thereon.

I do not believe in canon. Not in the "there is no god" sense, but in the "it's more of a guideline than a rule," sense. Yes, without the efforts of the creators, there'd be no Buffy the Vampire Slayer for fans to write about. No Highlander, no X-Files, no Angel, no Stargate: SG-1, etc. That doesn't mean that everything they create is wonderful. As beccadg noted in the comments, even the creators disavow some of the canon they create, and they change the backstory sometimes.

Why shouldn't fanfic writers do the same?

X-Files was swell for a while. Three, maybe four seasons. But I stopped paying attention when it became clear to me that Chris Carter did not have a master chart of the conspiracy on the wall in his office. He was making it up as he went, and the shape of the conspiracy Fox Mulder was trying to unravel changed from week to week to suit the needs of this week's story. Which meant that the 'arc' stories were, in fact, nothing of the kind. I continued watching X-Files for a while longer, but only the non-arc MOTW (monster of the week) episodes. And at that, I gave up on the show completely two or three seasons before it lurched to a halt.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer ended after Season Four in my universe. The introduction of Dawn was a cry for help, a confession of creative bankruptcy, and a harbinger of doom. The Emperor's New Clothes. A big, steaming pile dumped rudely in the middle of hte living room carpet. Need I go on, or has my distaste for Dawn and all that follows been adequately expressed? I know that there are many fans who loved the last three seasons of Buffy, and some who think it was never better. To them, I say Are you mad? Whatever floats your boat, I guess. But I feel no obligation to let that stuff infect fanfic I write (or read).

Angel lasted only two seasons. My feelings about Connor's addition to the show are almost identical to my feelings about Dawn on BtVS. What the hell was Joss's sudden fetish for magical teenage siblings/offspring? Or, in this case, for the sparkless, cliched Joanie loves Chachi Cordy loves Angel stuff? For God's sake, people, if anyone was smart enough and self-aware enough to know how bad an idea that was, it was Cordelia. Even if--and it's a big if--she fell for Angel, she's smart enough to bury that self-destructive longing under a heavy layer of self-preservation. Then there was Cordy n' Connor, ever-increasing cast bloat, and... No. Two seasons, tops.

Highlander ran only four and a half seasons. There was no Ahriman arc. Richie is alive and well and living on the banks of the River Denial. And this isn't only about Richie. The Ahriman storyline butchered four and a half years of carefully written shades of gray, a "talmudic discussion with swords" as someone put it once (of right, wrong, good and evil, and how to make hard choices in an imperfect world) and replaced it with a silly black and white morality play wherein Eeevil (in the form of a demon) was defeated by a Long-Prophesied Hero (tm) employing the awesome power of Tai Chi meditation. Argh.

There've been some good fanfic stories written that took these canon events as, well, canon and made the stories work. I won't deny that. But fanfic is all about taking the basics of someone else's stories and running with them. Different characters, alternate endings, crossovers. There's no reason to be bound by any particular point of canon, and especially not the most egregiously dumb parts.

Comments

[seawasp]

I'm a believer in canon. I'll permit you to pick and choose your canon, to a point, but there are limits. Sometimes it's obvious when the limits are being exceeded, sometimes it takes a bit of thought. Many anime fandoms go over the line constantly (the Gundam Wing fics where the only similarity between the original characters and setting were the names of the characters, for instance).

(Connor in Angel was Van from Escaflowne, in case you're really wondering. Joss did Buffy based on Sailor Moon to a large extent; Escaflowne had its influence in Angel)


By the way, for some reason your LJ -- and, so far, ONLY your LJ -- shows on my screen as single-word lines (so one post is many screens long).

[sinanju.livejournal.com]

Hmm. Maybe it's the formatting I used that's screwing up the format for you, though it looks okay to me.

There's no excuse for Connor or Dawn, in my opinion. None. No matter who or what Joss was cribbing from.

And I'll agree with your follow-up that you can go too far in the buffet-style approach to what is or isn't canon. That's why I say the various series ended where they did. Anything prior to that remains in canon, though I may employ artistic license to simply not refer to a story/event I think doesn't make sense. Just because I concede that it happened, I don't have to address it. But the cut-off points come when something happens that is simply unbearable.